Austin, Texas soon may be the next city in America that bans declawing.
The anti-declawing bill in Austin went before the Austin Animal Advisory Commission on September 10, 2018, where it was unanimously approved. The bill will head to the Health and Human Services Committee before eventually going before the Austin City Council. Here is the link to the video from this hearing. It is in Item 4. Hearing for the Austin Anti-declawing bill
Many ethical, no-declaw veterinarians and other animal welfare leaders spoke out in support of the bill and talked about the facts and studies that show how harmful and mutilating declawing is to a cat.
People who spoke out in favor of the bill, Dr Katrina Breitreiter of South Austin Cat Hospital, Dr Nicole Martell-Moran of Feline Medical Center, Dr Roy Smith of Central Texas Cat Hospital, Dr Taia Lubitz, Monica Frenden of Austin Pets Alive, Sheila Smith of Shadow Cats, Anne Zabolio of Thundering Paws, and John Garrison, a biochemist and biologist.
There were two people who spoke out against the bill. Dr Gina Vance, President of the Capital Area Veterinary Medical Association (16.40 min. mark in video) and one of their member declawing vets, Dr Richard Reinap, Bee Cave Veterinary Clinic (13.50 min mark in video).
Dr Reinap and Dr Vance both stated the CAVMA position on this bill and said, “We oppose the current version of the proposed ordinance because it compromises the veterinary, doctor, client, patient relationship.
Dr Gina Vance went on to say, “The decision to perform any veterinary treatment or therapy should be made by the pet owner and the veterinarian on a case-by-case basis within the context of a veterinary doctor client patient relationship.”
Commissioner Ryan Clinton asked Dr Vance, “Is elective declawing for non-medical reasons a treatment or therapy?”
Dr Gina Vance replied, “It could be considered a behavioral treatment.”
Dr Gina Vance also stated, “We try everything we can to talk people out of it.”
In my opinion, after years of researching and looking into how veterinary practices in America address declawing, this is a lie.
The majority of declawing vet practices in America do NOT do everything they can to talk people out of declawing their cats, in fact, it’s the opposite. They offer declawing as a standard and common procedure and even make it cheaper if the cat owner has the declaw done with a spay or neuter.
Commissioner Ryan Clinton asked the 5 veterinarians this question, “Is an elective declawing for non-medical reasons a diagnosis, treatment, correction, change, manipulation, relief or prevention of animal disease, deformity, defect, injury, or other physical condition of the animal?”
* The Councilman also had to narrow this question down and ask Dr Gina Vance, “What is physical condition of the animal that is treated by a declaw?” Dr Gina Vance answered, “The ability or the likelihood for the animal to harm the owner potentially, maybe with the scratching or making it incompatible for that animal to stay in that owner’s home is the potential there.” (43 minute mark of the video)
Dr. Katrina Breitreiter, “No.” South Austin Cat Hospital
Dr Taia Lubitz, “No.”
Dr. Nicole Martell-Moran, “No, it is not.” Feline Medical Center, Houston
Dr Roy Smith, “No.” Central Texas Cat Hospital, Round Rock
(*A spot check on how Dr Reinap’s Bee Cave Veterinary Clinic addresses declawing when a cat owner calls to make a spay/declaw appointment. An employee said that the price of a spay/declaw is $600- $690 and you have to have a $49 exam to discuss declawing with the doctor and see if that’s what you still want to do. If that’s what you want to do after the exam you can schedule the appointment for the procedures. There isn’t any information on Bee Cave Veterinary Clinic’s website about the facts about declawing or the easy, humane options.)
How the spokesman from the New Jersey Veterinary Medical Association lied to legislators. NJVMA Lies
How the New York State Veterinary Medical Society lied to legislators- NYSVMS Lies
A tv station did a segment about this bill in Austin and interviewed a declawing vet, Dr Ian Voelzel, who stated that laser declaw is least invasive and least painful. KXAN interview
I sent an email to this vet in the story, to his CAT FRIENDLY Practice and AAHA hospital, Westlake Animal Hospital in Austin, Westlake Animal Hospital Website and asked these important questions.
The manager of Westlake Animal Hospital wrote this reply.
“Thank you for reaching out. Unfortunately, we will be unable to participate in your story at this time. Due to the amount of requests we receive, we are currently limited to responding to traditional news media organizations. We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause and again, thank you for your interest.”
Since Dr Voelzel didn’t have the time to answer my questions about how he addresses declawing at his practice, we had to look into it this way.
A spot check on how Dr Ian Voelzel’s Westlake Animal Hospital addresses declawing with a cat owner when they called and asked for declawing prices.
Westlake Animal Hospital- Austin Texas
Researcher asked for the price for a spay/declaw and employee said it is $831- $882.
Researcher asked for the price of a 4 paw declaw and the employee said that they do offer 4 paw declaws but you have to have a vet tech write up a treatment plan to get a price for it. They said that you need an exam and pre-op blood work and they can definitely go ahead and schedule the spay/declaw if the cat is healthy enough for the procedures. Researcher asked for the best vet for the declaw procedure and the employee said that all the doctors do them and it’s a routine procedure.
Another employee said that they don’t have an age limit for declaws.
A researcher called for a neuter/declaw for a 10 week old kitten and the employee said that a neuter is $424-$442 2 paw declaw is $700-800. When the researcher asked for the best vet to perform the declaw, the employee said that all the vets are good at it.
The employee said that if the kitten had any residual teeth at the surgery time they would have to be removed & there would be extra charges. Researcher asked if there would be any long term effects from the declaw and the employee said no, not that she’s aware of and stated that they use a laser.
When asked about declawing a 2 year old cat and if there is an age limit the employee said that they didn’t think there was a age limit but that’s something the doctor would have to decide in a consult appointment.
Below are the results of a July 2018, random study of how some Cat Friendly Practices in Texas address declawing.
CAT FRIENDLY Practices in Texas
1) VCA Park Cities Animal Hospital in Dallas
Employee was asked if they can do a declaw with a spay and said, “ We certainly are able to do the declaw.”
Declaw/spay is around $1000. They also give an antibiotic injection and send you home with Purina’s Yesterday’s News litter.
They said that they have 3 vets who do declaws relatively frequently and they use a scalpel.
They said that you can bring the cat in for an exam on the morning of the procedure. They said in 10-14 days the kitty is back to normal.
2) VCA Castle Hill Companion Animal Hospital
Employee said that they do declaws but their laser isn’t working so they currently aren’t performing them and aren’t sure if and when it will be fixed. Employee said, “If you do get it done, make sure it’s with a laser.”
3) Kelly Hill Country Animal Hospital
They said that they do declaws and there’s a little discount if you do it at the same time as a spay/neuter. A spay/ laser declaw is $681.
They said that their vet does them pretty regularly. They said that the laser is less painful, less swelling, and speeds up the healing process.
4) Kyle Animal Hospital
They said that you have to make an appointment for an exam and to see if the cat is a candidate for the declaw. They said that not all cats can be declawed. A declaw is $120-160.
5) Kitten to Cat Hospital in South Lake
They said that they do a laser declaw and their vet does a fair amount of declaws. A spay/declaw is $805. They said that they only do declaw with spay/neuters and usually in 14-21 days the cat will be healed.
6) Riverchase Animal Hospital
The spay/declaw is $518. They said that both doctors are experienced at declaws, they use a scalpel, and they do them regularly.
7) Highland Park Animal Hospital
The employee said that a spay/declaw is $650-750. All of their vets do declaws but that Dr Dixon and Dr Vargo do the most declaws and are their cat specialists. They said that they surgically remove the nail where it meets the finger. They said that in 10-14 days the kitty will be back to normal.
8) Lexington Blvd Animal Hospital
When researcher asked for the price of a spay/declaw, the employee asked, “Just the front two?” A spay/4 paw declaw is $724 and the cat will stay for 3 nights. They said their vet who does the declaws, Dr Stanley, is a feline specialist and she uses a scalpel for the declaws.
9) Northern Oaks Bird and Animal Hospital- AAHA
Employee said that a spay/declaw is $550. They said that either of their vets are good at the declaws. They said that the cat won’t have their claws there to do the damage and the cat usually doesn’t know anything has happened after the declaw. They use the guillotine clippers for the declaws and a laser for healing after the declaw.
10) Advanced Pet Care of Clearlake
The employee said that their spay/declaw is $700-$750, their vet, Dr Rush uses a laser and does them regularly. They said that they use a laser and it cauterizes when it cuts and it helps with inflammation and they feel better. They said that there’s a vet tech surgery assistant helping and they have a good team. They give a pain injection which lasts 3 days and an antibiotic that lasts 2 weeks.
11) Bent Tree Animal Hospital
The employee said that a spay/declaw is $404.40, their vet, Dr Kimball uses a scalpel and does declaws regularly.
12) The Cats Meow Veterinary
Employee says that their vets do laser declaws regularly. A spay/declaw is $585, the cat won’t have to have bandages, the laser takes off the claws so that there’s no bleeding, and they use 3 different modes of pain meds.
13) Perky Paws Pet Hospital
The employee said that a spay/declaw is $305 and their vet, Dr Farmer, uses a scalpel. They said that she’s a Cat Friendly doctor and has extra skills when it comes to cats.
They said a declaw is the same as chopping off a finger and the cat will have to stay overnight. They recommend getting the pain medication for $48 but it is optional.
14) Zippivet in Austin
They don’t declaw cats. The employee said that it’s not a good practice to declaw cats and that it’s horrible because it’s cutting off the ends of their little toes. They said to look it up and read about it. They said it can cause arthritis and pain for the rest of their life. Also, the cat has to go through pain for weeks from the procedure. Employee said that they don’t know of any vet in Texas that will do it. They talked about the alternatives like getting scratching poles and a product called Feliscratch which directs the cat to scratch on the appropriate things.
15) Feline Medical Center in Houston
They don’t declaw cats. The employee said that they stopped because it causes the cats a lot of long term issues like arthritis and behavioral issues. They talked about the alternatives like nail trims, soft paws, and giving the cats the appropriate scratching options. They said that they can help with tips and training if needed.
16) Metro Paws Animal Hospital in Dallas
They don’t declaw cats. The employee said that they advise against it and their vets aren’t comfortable doing them. They talked about the alternatives like getting proper scratching posts.
17) VCA Oso Creek Animal Hospital in Corpus Christie
The employee said that they no longer do them unless there’s a medical reason for the cat. Another employee said that they don’t declaw cats because it’s a company policy. They said that it’s a controversy because some people declaw their cats because they are scratching furniture or because they are aggressive.